BOTTOMLINE: ALL of these Buzz Words want you to do the SAME THING…DIDLS!!!
Simply put, what the student is being asked to do is to identify an ABSTRACTION (the attitude) through the use of CONCRETE elements (DIDLS) diction, imagery, details, language, and syntax.
An effective method for analyzing tone is to keep a dialectical journal of the elements of tone while the student is reading the selection. The dialectical journal helps the student keep track of those concrete elements of tone, and provides the opportunity to develop commentary on those elements.
Fold a piece of paper in half lengthwise. List the concrete element on the left side of the page. The student should write one to two sentences of commentary for each concrete element listed directly opposite the element on the right side of the page. The concrete element is ‘how” an attitude is characterized. Commentary is “why” that element helps to characterize an attitude.
EXAMPLE:
Evidence Commentary
“How is the Attitude is Characterized”, “Why”,“What is revealed?”,
“Concrete detail”, “Quotation” “What is learned?”
“burden” (diction) A burden is something that weighs you down. A thing that you carry with you, despite the load.
As you read various selections or chapters, keep a dialectical journal with following requirements:
FYI
Some areas may have the same evidence. This is fine for it shows that the elements are fluid.
After the first timed writing is completed, then ask the student the following questions.