Case Studies of Research Based Curricula in College Based Higher Education (CBHE) Mick Healey
(firstname.lastname@example.org), Higher Education Consultant and Researcher, Emeritus Professor University of Gloucestershire (www.mickhealey.co.uk);
(email@example.com), Higher Education Consultant, Emeritus Professor Oxford Brookes University http://www.alanjenkins.info); and
(firstname.lastname@example.org), Assistant Director, Learning and Teaching Enhancement Unit, Canterbury Christ Church University (http://www.canterbury.ac.uk/Support/learning-teaching-enhancement-unit/Staff/JohnLea/)
The following summary case studies from the UK, Australia, Canada, Ireland, and United States were collected as part of an HE Academy funded project. They are categorised under the following groupings:
Arts, Design, Media and Humanities (5)
Business, Hospitality, Law, Sport and Tourism (7)
Education, Social, Environmental and Health Sciences (14)
Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (13)
Readers are invited to send us additional case studies of research-based curricula in CBHE using the same format as the ones which follow. In particular:
Be brief (c250-350 words)
Be specific as to what the student does
Guide other staff/faculty how to shape their practice; so point to the key things they need to consider
If available, provide details of relevant web sites and/or publications that provide further detail.
Please send your (draft) case studies to Alan Jenkins (email@example.com).
This file is accessible at: http://www.heacademy.ac.uk/college-based-he/research-based-curricula.
Arts, Design, Media and Humanities
1.1 Shaping dissertation research in dance and music theatre: critical approaches and shifting methodologies at London Studio Centre, UK
London Studio Centre’s BA (Hons) Theatre Dance programme, validated by Middlesex University, prioritises technical excellence in dance/music theatre performance and creative practice, based on a clear grasp of dance history and culture. The dissertation forms a key part of the Level 6 module M301 – Research: Putting Theory into Practice (40 credits). Modules at Levels 4 and 5 prepare the students for this task, establishing study skills and research methods appropriate for HE and developing critical and analytical tools to locate different dance practices, including the students’ own creative practice, in a wider cultural context. The integration of theory and practice through dissertation research encourages students to develop the transferable graduate skills needed when they enter the professional field, and indeed when they exit it, considering professional dance may be a relatively short-lived career. Furthermore, recent methodological shifts in the wider field of dance studies have led students, in conjunction with tutors, to develop tailor-made research methodologies. There is a breadth of interdisciplinary theoretical frameworks, combining insights from dance studies as a discipline with theatre studies, cultural studies, psychology, anatomy/ physiology or sociology. Many students choose to study topics in the field of popular culture, in line with the recognition of popular dance and music theatre as meriting academic enquiry; however, this is not without its challenges due to the apparent lack of substantial bodies of literature in these areas. Also, practice-based research in choreography and dance on screen is becoming increasingly significant.
Sources: http://elearn.mdx.ac.uk/criticalenquiry/abstractUytterhoeven.htm; http://www.london-studio-centre.co.uk/courses/ba-hons-theatre-dance
1.2 Engaging students with the latest research and publications in architectural design at Adam Smith College, Dundee College and Abertay University, UK
This case study relates to a collaborative programme delivered across two colleges and a university. The BSc (Hons) Sustainable Architectural Design is an award made by the University of Abertay Dundee and delivered at third and fourth year (levels 9 and 10 of SCQF) jointly by Adam Smith College, Dundee College and Abertay across each of the campus locations. The programme only draws applicants from colleges with existing HND awards therefore all of the students have come through the FE experience.
In the module, Construction Contracts and Environmental Law, the students are set specific weekly preparation tasks; motivating and obtaining deep learning and ensuring enquiry into latest research and publications is expected and tested across the class. The students are given prior notice of materials they can bring to class – but in the event that some students will not, for whatever reason, undertake preparation to further their knowledge for dealing with the class-based problems and issues, they are allowed to use their laptops, iPads, iPhones or other technology to access whatever information they might need to deal with the class-based problems, issues and tasks in addition to the questions at the commencement of a session. They are provided with either a detailed problem prior to class or a knowledge area to research and bring notes on which they are allowed to access during the tasks.
Students are questioned using a random system under which they all know they could be asked any question and there is some peer pressure for students to work together and prepare for the classes. The more answers correct the less time spent ‘teaching’ and more time discussing and engaging with the issues and problems, with the tutor’s role to clarify misunderstanding and fill gaps in knowledge.
Source: Correspondence with Eddie Simpson (firstname.lastname@example.org)
1.3 Developing a research orientation in undergraduate creative arts in the Bachelor of Illustration at Northern Melbourne Institute of TAFE, Australia
The Bachelor of Illustration is a three-year undergraduate degree in the creative arts. Research is an essential component of the Bachelor of Illustration. Students investigate a wide range of visual art practices and draw on history, technology, commerce, media and cultural studies as they progress to analyse and critique the development of illustration and visual language. In the recent past two large mural projects were introduced in the first year of the program to establish a ‘research sensibility’ early in the program. These projects provide excellent industry-based opportunities for first year students to research and engage in an enterprise that has a clearly defined product at completion. The initial investigative research aims to encourage exploration and broad enquiry, through the use of the library to develop information and academic literacies through the creation of relevant reference lists, bibliographies as well as accessing and compiling community resources relevant to the particular project. In addition, these activities build the skills and techniques, that create a shared peer supported environment of enquiry and dialogue to reach identified outcomes. The projects also provide scope for initial independent research. During the early phase of the research there are factors for consideration that may involve the specific communities living within the intended locations of the artwork. In the Mural Projects example, the students’ investigative research directed their attention for the need to become aware of sensitive cultural, political and religious requirements for appropriate imagery for public display within a diverse ethnic mix. For the Child Care Mural Projects after initial research including parameters and constraints such as background exploration of subject matter, safety and enhancement, visual reference points related to the client, appropriate style, colour, generic stylised images of children, scaled designs for proportion, all students in the group submitted a range of designs. Subsequently, peer critique and peer review through facilitated group discussion created either a consensus decision where either an amalgamation of the designs or the best design was selected to be developed.
Sources:Correspondence with Colleen Morris(email@example.com) and Christine Spratt (firstname.lastname@example.org); http://www.nmit.edu.au/courses/bachelor_of_illustration
1.4 Developing of a creative research culture for ‘Top-up’ Fine Art students through providing a choice of dissertations at Somerset College of Art, Taunton, UK
To extend and deepen a research culture for students topping up to a BA Fine Art a departmental decision was taken to develop the research options available to students for their dissertation module. Students now have a choice of three forms:
The traditional 5,000-8,000 word Thesis module.
A 5,000-8,000 word Critical Commentary. This research form explores the students work and ideas about their own Fine Art practice.
A Special Project that requires a 3,000-5,000 word research document and the production of three pieces of studio work.
All three options have consistently proved popular with Fine Art students.
The diversity of research options empowers and motivates students; emphasises active learning; facilitates learning through the production of artefacts; and encourages reflective practice and first person enquiry. A sense of discovery, exploration and provisionality are therefore integrated into the research culture. Students are better able to develop their own interests and to engage deeply with learning processes. Learning strengths and weaknesses are better identified by students. Staff are challenged to respond to outputs from a creative range of learning and project forms.
Both staff and students need to consider very carefully the three types of research form, and the different assessment criteria each requires. Varied forms of assessment enhance the student learning experience and their insights into the nature of research. The distinctiveness of each research form is also highlighted. Conversely assuring standards across different forms requires careful discussion of marking criteria by staff. Students are placed in peer learning groups to support one another and, early on, to help discuss the relative merits of each of the research forms. A bridging module is also in place towards the end of the 2nd year to help students get started on their 3rd year so that the summer vacation can be used for primary and secondary research.
Source: Correspondence with Peter Hawkins (HawkinsP@somerset.ac.uk)
1.5 Integration of research-based learning with professional practice in the Art and Design (Foundation) Diploma (FdA) at Kingston College, UK Through industry links
A crucial aspect of the FdA one year Diploma in Art & Design is the necessary skill development to meet the demands of being a professional practitioner through live projects and industry experience. The interdisciplinary live project involves students conducting independent visual research into the commercial viability of their art & design practice, in order to produce a series of well-crafted products for a pop-up shop within the Bentalls Department Store in Kingston upon Thames. Research includes customer profiles, production lead-time, skills analysis and material costing, packaging and sale presentation. From inception, the project is externally focused, with client feedback from Bentalls on pricing, advertising strategies and point of sale organisation. Students need to synthesise and act on this information in order to produce a range of products that clearly demonstrate how visually orientated research meets the needs and demands of the client.
Hence students are provided with the opportunity for students to gain real world experience, and to explore ideas within a public realm. Moreover it helps the students prepare for year two, in which they are required to explore external links more independently.
Through community links
Research-orientated professional practice and skill development is also supported on the FdA Diploma in Art & Design through community links, including a collaborative project with Burlington Junior School in New Malden. This involves year one students gaining valuable teaching experience through running painting and drawing workshops alongside professional teachers. Research undertaken prior to delivery includes a skills analysis of the age group, national curriculum requirements (focussing on cognitive and creative development) and the implications of teaching a widely differentiated student group.
Sources: Correspondence with Rob Miller (email@example.com) and Deborah James (deborah.james@Kingston-College.ac.uk); http://www.kingston.ac.uk/undergraduate-course/art-design-foundation-diploma-2013/
Business, Hospitality, Law, Sport and Tourism
2.1 Linking first and second year assessment strategies through researching the need for a local sports development project in a work based learning module at West Herts College, UK
In the second semester of the first year (level 4) Foundation Degree in Sport Studies (FDSS) learners at West Herts College, an average of N=16 (2009-2013) students study a Sports Development module. One assessment method within this module involves researching the need for a local sports development project. Students complete a project proposal form which is then presented to a panel for assessment. This enables students to complete research based inquiry into the physical activity and coaching needs of the local community. In addition to meeting learning outcomes specific to Sports Development, cross module links with Sports Coaching and Study Skills modules are also embedded through the completion of this assessment activity.
In year 2 (level 5), students are encouraged to approach employers with their first year Sports Development project proposals, to fulfil the requirements of their double semester work based learning (WBL) module. On average seven out of ten students use this opportunity with others seeking projects linked with marketing and management. Within WBL, students are required to network with employers to find a niche in the employers’ market. Students develop, implement, analyse and reflect on their implemented project proposals and this forms the basis for a 5,000 word mini final project / dissertation. In addition students are also required to support each other in an online learning community through use of Blogs and Wiki’s throughout their project delivery, enabling them to maintain contact with each other and with teaching staff.
The nature of the inquiry based project in the first year enables learners to thoroughly research and investigate their potential projects prior to implementation in the second year, clearly showing study progression and academic skill development. Examples include: a proposal to increase female sports participation which resulted in a cricket enrichment programme at a local secondary school for year 8 females pupils and an employment opportunity for the FDSS student; a proposal to increase Sikh community sports opportunities which resulted in a varied sports enrichment programme at a local primary school within a Sikh community and established school-club links within the local area. The FDSS student involved in this later project was offered employment at the primary school and at the leisure centre at which a number of the school-club links were cemented.
Source: Correspondence with Charlotte Gale (Charlotte.Gale@westherts.ac.uk) 2.2 Students on the Foundation Degree Business Management and Enterprise undertake a management consultancy project at Sheffield College, UK
The management consultancy project is designed for second year (level 5) students to pull together the skills and knowledge they have gained during their time at the College by investigating an area of their own business or one that they work for. The students are given the role of external consultants who can look at the business objectively, while still using their contextual understanding to suggest a complex action plan for improvements on a particular area of the business. This topic area is decided on through a negotiation with course staff and the student’s manager/business need. The choice made depends on student and tutor expertise as well business objectives. Examples include: ‘Investigating the ways for Strawberry Student Homes to attract more students and increase letting of accommodation’; and ‘An investigation into possible investment options to expand current customer base at Clobber Print’.
The module is delivered predominantly online with regular opportunities for formal, individual, formative feedback planned into the sessions. Students are encouraged to be independent learners and to personalise their own learning. This means group sessions are not always useful as learners have different content/knowledge needs as well as different contexts in which they work. Students can choose the most appropriate method to share their findings. They are given the option of a YouTube video, a seminar, Q&A session or anything else they think is ‘appropriate’. So far all have chosen 15-20 min PowerPoint presentations. It is not required that the students implement their findings but the impact of their application must be assessed. The unit is vocationally focused rather than academically driven, although there should be examples of academic good practise employed. This means that the expectations are that the findings should be useful and should have been clearly justified within the business context.
Source: Correspondence with Joan Rudder (Joan.Rudder@sheffcol.ac.uk)and Alice Bailey (Alice.Bailey@sheffcol.ac.uk) 2.3 Student-led research journal in business at Newcastle College, UK
An understanding of academic publication as an integral component of scholarship is embedded within the final year undergraduate and Masters courses (levels 6 and 7) in business. Curriculum design emphasises a cross-disciplinary approach to research. The benefits of publication are communicated to all HE business students in terms of employability skills and preparation for further study.
A student-led on-line research journal has been established to disseminate student scholarship, usually the findings of dissertation projects, to an external audience. Entitled The Seven Bridges Management Journal (a title proposed by students), it provides a range of opportunities for their students, not only as authors but also as Editors, peer reviewers and members of the Editorial Board. Collaboration between staff and students is central to the ethos of the journal. The Editorial Board is composed of both staff and students, with students in the majority. Each submission is peer reviewed by at least one student and one staff member. The editor is selected from the student body and allocated a number of staff advisors. Some of the papers have been written by collaborative partnerships of staff and students.
Course leaders have noted that involvement in the journal seems to provide students with greater confidence in the value of their own work. Establishing a new student-led academic journal inevitably requires a considerable time commitment from associated staff, particularly in terms of guiding students through the publication process as peer reviewers and members of the Editorial Board. In time, it is envisaged that experienced students will begin to mentor new participants.
Sources: Correspondence with Jonathan Eaton (Jonathan.Eaton@ncl-coll.ac.uk); sevenbridges.ncl-coll.ac.uk; http://www.ncl-coll.ac.uk/higher-education/research-and-scholarly-activity
2.4 Marketing final year research project at Letterkenny Institute of Technology, Ireland
All students taking the Bachelor of Business (Honours) Marketing complete a major marketing research project as a partial requirement for the fulfilment of their BBS Honours Marketing. The Marketing Research Project (5 credits) module is the capstone marketing research module. Prior to this, all students complete two modules (equating to 10 credits) specifically related to the field and practice of marketing research. These modules are called Marketing Research Methods and Applied Marketing Research.
In the research capstone module learners must work in groups and source a business that has a research problem or opportunity that they can address. For example one group of learners recently worked with an established hotel in the locality to investigate the consumer decision-making process for the selection of a wedding venue in Co. Donegal. The methodology for this project included a focus group with five couples who were married recently in Co. Donegal and a structured survey (N = 100).
Learners are required to apply the principles of best practice marketing research throughout their project. They are required to design and justify a sound methodology, and execute that methodology, incorporating innovative marketing research techniques throughout. Learners present a copy of their research projects to the business. Learners are also required to maintain a personal log, detailing their individual research reflections, throughout the module.
The Marketing Research Project module (semester 8) is linked to a preceding module, Applied Marketing Research (semester 7). In this module, the continuous assessment requires learners to source a business that has a research problem or opportunity and design a suitable marketing research proposal to address that research opportunity. In the semester 8 Marketing Research Project module, learners revise the proposal and execute the proposed research.
The Marketing Research Project module is assessed by 100% Continuous Assessment. 80% of the marks available are for group work and the remaining 20% is for an individual submission. Group work is assessed in four stages; stage 1 (20% of group work) represents the literature review, stage 2 (20% of group work) represents the methodology, and stage 3 (40% of group work) represents the findings and analysis section. Learners are provided with marks and feedback on their performance at each of these three stages. Stage 4 (the final 20% of group work) is for the resubmission of the final document; the Marketing Research Report. This report is also presented to the business.
In the individual submission, worth 20% of the module, learners must detail their personal research reflections. This must include information on areas they had special responsibility for, reflection of the division of labour throughout the project, and reflection on the research limitations.
Sources: Correspondence with Vicky O’Rourke (firstname.lastname@example.org); http://www.lyit.ie/courses/businessstudies/lybbussbmarketing/
2.5 Introduction to academic publications in first year sports studies courses at Newcastle College, UK
Newcastle College has developed an approach for inducting students in research skills at the beginning of their first year (level 4) in their FdSc Applied Health & Exercise Science, Applied Sports Coaching Science, FdA Applied Sports Management & Development and Certificate of HE in Football Coaching courses.
In the first week of their study, students receive an induction session on academic writing which includes Harvard referencing and an introduction to the SPORTDiscus bibliographic database. As their first assignment, students are asked to access a specific article from SPORTDiscus and write a short analytical report highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of the argument presented. They are also required to include references to two other journal articles within their report. Upon submission, these assignments form the basis for individual discussions with their personal professional development tutor.
This approach to academic induction assesses the abilities of students to access online journal articles, critically assess them and produce a report using Harvard referencing. This forms the basis for any future developmental support provided on an individual basis. The article on which the report is based has been specifically chosen to be accessible by level 4 students (it even references autobiographies by Stuart Pearce, Bobby Robson and Michael Owen), as well as relevant to the courses of study. This activity demystifies the research process and demonstrates the academic rigour demanded within higher education as part of the wider induction process.
Sources: Jonathan Eaton (email@example.com);http://www.ncl-coll.ac.uk/higher-education/research-and-scholarly-activity
2.6 Learning and Development Practice Exhibition for first year students at North Lindsey College, UK
North Lindsey College is an associate college of the University of Lincoln with a range of higher education courses. To support their entry into higher education students taking business and management foundation degrees (approximately 50 students) take a year-long introductory module that helps them analyse, develop and enhance their approach to learning through independent research, drawing on learning and workplaces resources. An introductory exercise using learning theory, such as Kolb’s Learning Cycle, together with an audit and SWOT analysis helps students identify both their current skills and areas they needed to develop. Subsequently an interactive lecture programme based predominantly on the academic skills identified by individuals was devised by the module leader. Seminars focused on tasks that sought to encourage students to gather evidence of progression and explored how to exhibit this in an innovative and creative manner. The latter was reinforced by web 2.0 technologies such as online forums, multiple choices quizzes and e-journal articles on reflective practice.
At the culminating exhibition students showcase their specific skills development, in conjunction with learning theory; local employers, further education students and course applicants were invited to attend and view some of the demonstrations, whilst the module leader assessed each student via observation and question and answer. Examples included: a ballerina optical illusion on learning styles, a mock Bruno Mars ‘Lazy Day’ music video, and a 3D iceberg on critical thinking.
Source: Correspondence with Louisa Hill (firstname.lastname@example.org)
2.7 Second year business students undertake a research based paper at Bay of Plenty Polytechnic, Tauranga, New Zealand
The Polytechnic has a partnership with the University of Waikato to deliver the first 2 years of their business degrees through the NZ Dip Bus programme in Tauranga; students can then complete the remaining 3rd and 4th year (depending on which degree) in Tauranga or Hamilton.
Applied Management is a single semester research-based paper – generally undertaken in their second year - which requires student research teams to identify a management issue in an organisation, conduct research to identify problems and/or establish causes and recommend possible solutions. The paper necessitates collaboration between students and local organisations, and may involve solving problems identified by the organisation, or alternatively a deductive approach, exploring the application of a management concept, such as motivation, engagement or structure, using the organisation as a case study. Access to, and co-operation from the organisation is therefore a key component of successful project completion. Students work in teams to develop a research proposal outlining the background, rationale, research aims, methodology and an ethics statement. Research instruments are developed to gather primary data, a literature review scans relevant secondary data, and a research report and presentation outline the findings and recommendations. Finally students complete individual evaluations of the process.
For the majority of students, this is their first experience of research based study which necessitates the teaching of research methods, research ethics and writing a research proposal and report. Familiarisation with the ‘language’ of research is also needed. This material is covered in a series of seminars at the beginning of the semester, but once the proposal has been approved, research teams work independently under the supervision of the tutor, and tutors need to be aware of the varied level of support different groups and individuals may require in addition to academic guidance. Development of independent study skills is vital to student success. The research-based paper enables students to synthesise material studied in their other papers and provides students with the opportunity to investigate a management topic in depth. Results are excellent, in terms of student retention and success. Participants produce a tangible outcome which can be included in their graduate portfolio and the research and writing skills they learn prepare them for higher levels of study.
Source: Correspondence with Anne Bradley (Anne.Bradley@boppoly.ac.nz).
3.1 Engaging students with the research literature through discussion in Social Care at Shetland College, University of Highlands and Islands, UK
In the first year residential child care workers enrolled on the HNC Social Care programme at Shetland College, undertake the Protection of Individuals from Possible Harm and Abuse unit. Assignment requirements include focus on evidencing knowledge and understanding of relevant reports, enquiries or research. This provides an opportunity for the learners to be exposed to the wealth of available resources. Three specific activities structure directed study in advance of a two-hour action learning set (ALS):
Activity 1: read a research-based report and prepare a one-page summary identifying the purpose of the study, the sample, data gathering methods, ethical considerations and key findings (each student gets a different report);
Activity 2: read a serious case review summary and prepare a one-page list of key points drawn from the recommendations (each student gets a different case);
Activity 3: read a serious case review meta-analysis summary.
The ALS augments learning enabled via the directed study. Specifically each student presents their summary of the research-based report picking up each element of Activity 1, thus evidencing the early development of research-critique skills. The range of reports featured enables the breadth of potential sources of harm/abuse to be considered. Group discussion makes links back to the work setting, identifying implications for practice. Each member of the group then discusses what they learned from their allocated serious case review, making connections with the findings of the meta-analysis. The aim is to help the learners see that recommendations from single cases are part of a bigger picture which provides overall learning lessons.
In summary, the ALS evidences research-led practice - learning about current research in the discipline and research-tutored practice - engaging in research discussions. It introduces the learners to reports and research in a specific field, invites them develop critique skills and to connect research with practice. Analysis naturally occurs within the discussion, enhancing the learners’ knowledge base whilst supporting their development as questioning practitioners.
Source: Correspondence with Fiona Smart (email@example.com)