Score
|
Clarity and Tone
|
Mechanics and Conventions
|
Use of Sources and Documentation
|
Content
|
5
|
The student clearly identifies their thesis and uses clear, concise language to engage the reader. The writing is focused with a consistent style, tone, and focus on the topic.
|
The paper is free of spelling and grammar errors with accurate and consistent citations. The paper is in the appropriate format and the assignment directions are fulfilled.
|
The paper uses a number of primary and secondary sources with correct citation following a known style. The reader will have no problem following up on the sources used. The content taken from sources help to back up the original content and is used sparingly. There is more original content in the essay than cited.
|
Follows the assignment directions accurately in regards to the topic and stays on topic throughout the paper. The reader has a clear idea of what they are discussing and can verbalize the thesis easily.
|
4
|
The student identifies their subject in clear (but not concise) language. The writing is not focused and the tone and style shifts.
|
The paper contains some (less than 5) spelling and/or grammar errors. The citations are correct and without error. The assignment directions are fulfilled. The paper is in an appropriate (though may not be the requested) format.
|
The paper uses a number of primary and secondary sources with accurate citations. The reader will have no problem following up on the sources. The content quoted in the essay may follow inconsistent formatting and/or may not be fully incorporated into the body of the paragraph. The insertion of quotes feels awkward at time.
|
Follows the topic but deviates from it at times. The reader may have some trouble verbalizing the thesis if asked.
|
3
|
The student states the subject but may not fully explore it. The writing is coherent but not concise with clear use of filler language. The writing may not be focused with clear style shifts.
|
The paper contains multiple spelling and/or grammar errors (more than 5). The citation style may be inconsistent, though the student does list all of their sources. The assignment directions may be fulfilled with paper using an inconsistent format (e.g. multiple font types in a sentence, pages with different spacing, inconsistent borders, etc.).
|
The paper uses some primary sources with references to the source material. The reader may have difficulty following up on the original sources due to either incorrect citations and/or lack of citations. The quotes used within the paper may not fully support the content and may be used as “filler” to gain page length.
|
The student discusses the topic occasionally but the paper consists of several main ideas. The reader may have trouble verbalizing the thesis.
|
2
|
The writing is rambling (content does not match the thesis) and a clear subject is presented but is not the one assigned. The writing lacks focus and contains an inconsistent writing style
|
The paper contains multiple spelling and/or grammar errors (more than 10) with incomplete citations. The assignment directions were not fulfilled. The paper format does not follow a known style (APA, MLA. Chicago).
|
The student used some sources and attempted to cite them following a known style. The reader may be able to follow up on the sources used but with difficulty. The quotes and facts taken from sources are not incorporated into the body of the paper. The student may have used more quotes than original content.
|
The student attempted to follow the topic but it was only present in one or two sections of the paper. The reader will have trouble verbalizing the thesis.
|
1
|
The essay lacks a thesis and the writing is incoherent at times. The student had trouble with sentence structure, maintaining a consistent voice, and lacked clear transitions and sequence of ideas.
|
The essay contains numerous spelling and/or grammar errors with inconsistent or incomplete citations. The format does not follow a follow a known style (APA, MLA, Chicago) and is inconsistent.
|
The student used some sources. The reader would have a difficult time finding or following up on the sources used. Quotations seemed out of place and were not fully incorporated into the body of the essay. Or, the student used more quoted content than original ideas.
|
The topic discussed, at times, was the topic assigned but primarily consisted of off-topic discussion.
|
0
|
The essay did not meet the minimum requirements of the assignment. This includes cases of plagiarism or not turning anything in for grading.
|
There are numerous spelling and grammar errors. Citations for sources are either missing or incomplete.
|
Failed to use primary and/or secondary sources to supplement ideas. The reader would be unable to follow where the student located the facts stated in the essay.
|
The topic discussed was not the one assigned.
|